Comprehensive Deep-Dive: Brendan Cole Fires Blunt Criticism at Amy Dowden Following Her Early Strictly Exit
Former Strictly Come Dancing professional dancer Brendan Cole has sparked a fresh wave of controversy after delivering a scathing public critique of fellow pro Amy Dowden, following her early elimination from the 2026 series.
1. The Core Criticisms and “Counting Steps” Claims
Speaking out in the wake of Chris Appleton and Amy Dowden becoming the first couple eliminated from the competition, Cole did not hold back in evaluating Dowden’s recent performances on the show.
-
Questioning Pro-Level Execution: Cole bluntly asserted that Dowden has “not been up to the challenge” in recent years, pointing to consecutive early exits as a statistical indicator.
-
The Technical Critique: Singling out her choreography and teaching style with Appleton, Cole claimed that it was overly obvious she was having to verbally count him through steps on the dancefloor, arguing that a professional’s job is to make the routine look seamless and internalised for the celebrity.
2. Backlash and the Wider Debate
Cole’s remarks immediately drew heavy division among Strictly fans and commentators, amplifying an already emotional week for Dowden.
-
A Tough Run of Luck: Supporters of Dowden quickly jumped to her defense, noting that her recent seasons have been plagued by extraordinary hurdles—including her courageous return following her breast cancer battle, a foot injury, and being paired with novices facing steep learning curves.
-
Cole’s History of Outspokenness: Longtime viewers were unsurprised by the blunt assessment, recalling that Cole—who famously departed the BBC show himself after years of fiery critiques and strong personality clashes—has frequently maintained a reputation for giving unvarnished, no-holds-barred opinions on contemporary professional choreography and judging standards.